|Spectator 6 posts||
With inexperienced partners in club training? Overzealous opponents in tournaments?
|Regular 92 posts||
I find that in any type of martial arts there are a decent amount of minor injuries at low ranks because they don't have the knowledge, but they also don't have the technique yet to really hurt someone. Then I see very few injuries in the middle ranks because they still aren't quite good enough to seriously hurt someone, but now have much better control Then, at the top there are very few injuries, but they tend to be pretty bad. Broken bones, dislocated joints... It doesn't happen very often because they now have the skill to stop when they need to, but every so often something is calculated wrong and you land weird. I've seen this trend in every martial arts style that I've done, both standup and grappling.
Blue Belt - Gracie JJ
3rd Degree Black Belt - Shorin Ryu
Red Belt w/ two stripes - Soo Bahk Do
|Spectator 10 posts||
The majority of injuries can be avoided with self restraint with regard to competition. When it comes to general training, injuries occur mainly through just a momentary lapse. Thats life I suppose.
"Shear blunt trauma, followed by technical form!"
|Spectator 6 posts||
I think most people would agree with both of you -- and I think the point about injuries being more severe and less frequent with advanced students is probably applicable to most martial arts.
Looking from outside of the (B)JJ ranks, though, and having seen (and felt) a bit of demonstration and some youtube clips, I'd be much more reluctant to put myself in a grappling/competition situation with an inexperienced or untrusted opponent than I would in a standup karate match or sparring. I think what makes me wary of JJ is the locks and that it seems more difficult to control techniques if you are not on your feet. I love the few BJJ moves I've been taught but I'm reluctant to try them at their normal pace outside of very formalised learning situations. The lightest of demos have left me with a sore neck and joint pains, and I'm reasonably young and flexible. So I wonder what the experiences of long-term JJ people are.